Skip to content
A wooden watch box on a table

Gifts for watch lovers

Best gifts for watch lovers

Buying a watch for someone who already loves watches is a trap. Buying for the watches they already own is not — and the best gift here has a published price.

By Sawyer V. · Published

The short answer

For someone who already owns watches, give what they won't buy themselves: an Erika's Originals MN strap cut to their wrist, or a Barrington winder if they own more automatics than wrists. Or pay for their next service — Seiko publishes $176 for a 4R overhaul, a gift with a known price.

Buying a watch for someone who collects watches almost never works — taste in watches is specific, and they have usually already decided what they want next. Buying something for the watches they already own almost always does. Straps, a winder for a rotation, or the one gift every mechanical watch eventually needs: a service.

Everything below is chosen on published specifications, the same way as the watches on this site. For a watch as the gift, see the gift guide.

On prices: we publish no figure we have not verified today, so every buy button reads "Check price on Amazon". Service prices on this page are the manufacturers' own published figures.

How we picked

We have not worn these watches. What follows is what we checked instead, on documents you can open yourself — the same criteria, in the same order, on every roundup on this site. The full method is on the methodology page.

  1. 01Useful to what they own

    The gift should make a watch they already have better — a strap in the right width, a winder for a rotation — rather than compete with their taste.

  2. 02Hard to get wrong

    Straps come in lug widths. Check the width before buying; every watch on this site lists it.

  3. 03Quality they would not buy themselves

    The strap with the stated steel grade, the winder with published turns per day.

  4. 04Nothing that opens the case

    Case-back tools and home kits are how water resistance gets lost. Leave the inside of the watch to a watchmaker.

Disclosure · Some links below are Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through one we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It does not decide what goes on this page or in what order — here is exactly how that works.

01

Erika's Originals MN Strap

Best for: The gift they will wear every day

Watch strap

Erika's Originals

The elastic Marine Nationale pattern, made to your wrist measurement rather than to a hole.

Sold direct by Erika's Originals

We earn nothing on this link. Erika's Originals sells it directly.

An MN strap is the one strap enthusiasts consistently call the most comfortable they own, and Erika's makes it to a measured length rather than a hole — which is exactly the kind of small luxury people rarely buy for themselves.

Sold in widths from 18 to 24mm and lengths from 150mm to 230mm, with titanium, DLC, bronze and brass hardware offered. Sold direct only; we earn nothing on it.

Every other strap here fits your wrist to the nearest hole. This one is elastic and cut to a stated length in millimeters, which is why it is the one that works on a heavy watch and a hot day. Sold direct only — we earn nothing on it.

Published specifications for the Erika's Originals MN Strap
MaterialIn-house woven elastic nylon webbing over a latex-free Spandex core
AdjustmentElastic and micro-adjustable — no holes to choose between
Hardware optionsBead-blasted titanium (20, 21 and 22mm), black DLC, solid bronze and brass, each a paid upgrade
Widths18 to 24mm
Lengths150mm to 230mm, plus custom sizing
MadeHand assembled in Valencia
Warranty12 months; 3 months on straps made from vintage or second-hand materials

Specifications read from Erika's Originals product page, Original MN strap.

02

Barrington Oxford Single Watch Winder

Best for: Someone with more automatics than wrists

Watch winder

Barrington

Five TPD settings, three directions and a published winding cycle, on batteries or mains.

Check price on Amazon

#ad Affiliate link · We publish no price we have not verified today

A winder earns its place only for someone with a rotation or a calendar watch, and for them the Barrington is the one to give: five published turns-per-day settings, three directions, and a published winding cycle.

It runs on batteries or mains and parks the watch at 12 o'clock. If they own one automatic and wear it daily, give something else — the [winder guide](/guides/best-watch-winders) explains why.

The only winder here that publishes its entire winding cycle — how many turns, over how long, followed by how much rest. That is what lets you match it to a caliber instead of guessing, and Barrington publishes a turns-per-day database for exactly that.

Published specifications for the Barrington Oxford Single Watch Winder
Turns per day650, 750, 850, 1,000 or 1,950 — five fixed settings
DirectionClockwise, counter-clockwise or alternating
CycleTen rotations in about 90 seconds, then a pause; 12 hours winding, 12 hours at rest
Rest positionStops with the watch at 12 o'clock
Power4 x AA batteries, stated 60-70 days, or mains via USB-C; UK, US and EU adapters supplied
MotorJapanese, described by Barrington as ultra-quiet
Size and weight12cm W x 12.5cm H x 19cm D, 800g
Warranty2-year international

Specifications read from Barrington product page, Oxford Single Winder.

03

Barton Top Grain Leather Quick Release Strap

Best for: The easiest gift that still feels considered

Watch strap

Barton

Aniline-dyed top grain leather on 316L hardware, with tool-free quick-release bars.

Check price on Amazon

#ad Affiliate link · We publish no price we have not verified today

A good leather strap changes how a watch looks more than anything short of a new watch, and quick-release bars mean the recipient can fit it in seconds without tools or a trip to a jeweler.

Barton uses 316L buckles where many leather straps use plated base metal, and states a money-back guarantee on fit.

Leather is a consumable — sweat and water end every leather strap eventually — so the right leather strap is the one that is cheap to replace and swaps in seconds without tools. This one is both, and the buckle is 316L where most leather straps at this level use plated base metal.

Published specifications for the Barton Top Grain Leather Quick Release Strap
LeatherTop grain bovine leather, hand selected and aniline dyed
LiningA thin, treated leather strip on the underside
StitchingRuns the full perimeter, with extra loops at the spring-bar end for strength
Hardware316L stainless steel buckle
Quick releaseIntegrated quick-release spring bars
LengthsStandard fits 5-8in wrists; long fits 7.5-9in
GuaranteeBarton states a money-back guarantee on fit

Specifications read from Barton Watch Bands, Leather Quick Release design features.

04

ZULUDIVER AquaWave Rubber Strap (MKII)

Best for: Someone with a dive watch on a bracelet

Watch strap

ZULUDIVER

A 1960s tropic-pattern dive strap in HNBR rubber, on a 316-grade buckle.

Check price on Amazon

#ad Affiliate link · We publish no price we have not verified today

Most dive watches arrive on a bracelet, and a proper rubber strap is the gift that turns one into a summer watch. The AquaWave takes the vintage tropic pattern and makes it in HNBR rubber with a saltwater-resistant 316-grade buckle.

20mm and 22mm only, with ten holes across a 108-195mm range. Check the watch's lug width first.

Ten holes across a 108-195mm range is the most adjustable fit on this site, and a perforated tropic pattern lets a wet wrist dry. ZULUDIVER states the buckle grade and the rubber compound — two things most rubber straps leave you to guess.

Published specifications for the ZULUDIVER AquaWave Rubber Strap (MKII)
MaterialHNBR (hydrogenated nitrile butadiene rubber)
Widths and taper20mm tapering to 18mm; 22mm tapering to 20mm
Thickness4mm tapering to 2.4mm
Length130mm long side, 80mm short side, ten holes; fastens between 108mm and 195mm
HardwareSaltwater-resistant 316-grade stainless steel buckle, 2mm tongue; standard, IP black or antique bronze
Quick releaseQuick-release spring bars fitted
WarrantyNot stated on the product page

Specifications read from ZULUDIVER product page, AquaWave (MKII).

05

Crown & Buckle Supreme NATO

Best for: The NATO upgrade

Watch strap

Crown & Buckle

316L hardware and a 1.4mm seatbelt weave — the only line here that states the steel grade.

Sold direct by Crown & Buckle

We earn nothing on this link. Crown & Buckle sells it directly.

If they already wear NATO straps, give them the one with the steel grade stated: Crown & Buckle reserves 316L hardware for the Supreme line, with a smooth 1.4mm seatbelt weave.

At 1.4mm it is thicker than a standard NATO, so check it clears the case back of their watch. Sold direct; we earn nothing on this link.

304L and 316L both say stainless on the listing; only one of them shrugs off sweat and salt water over years. Crown & Buckle is unusual in telling you which grade you are getting on which line, and reserves 316L for this one.

Published specifications for the Crown & Buckle Supreme NATO
MaterialSeatbelt weave ballistic nylon, 1.4mm thick
HardwareMachined 316L stainless steel, brushed or matte black PVD
FinishingUltrasonically cut, leaving sealed tips and sizing holes
The rest of the rangeStandard 1.25mm and Premium 1.25mm on 304L hardware; Heavy Duty 1.6mm on 304L

Specifications read from Crown & Buckle, Learn About NATO Straps.

The best gift here isn't an object: pay for the service

Every mechanical watch needs an overhaul roughly every three years, and it is the purchase every owner puts off. Two brands publish exactly what it costs, which makes it a gift you can price in advance:

From Seiko's and Tissot's published US service price lists.
ServicePublished price
Seiko 7S overhaul$137
Seiko 4R overhaul (Seiko 5, Turtle, Presage)$176
Seiko 6R overhaul (Alpinist, SPB453)$296
Seiko 8R chronograph overhaul$373
Tissot complete mechanical service (US)$210, with 24 months on the work
From Seiko's and Tissot's published US service price lists.

Check the lug width first

Every strap gift depends on one number: the width between the lugs. It is printed on the manufacturer's page for most watches and listed on every watch on this site. Odd widths — 19mm and 21mm — are common on dress watches and on several watches we rate well, and Barton's silicone straps are one of the few ranges that stock them.

What we would not buy

  • A multi-watch winder for someone with one automatic. It stays mostly empty and a single watch worn daily never needs winding.
  • Strap multipacks with no stated specifications. No thickness, no steel grade, usually plated hardware.
  • Anything that opens the case. Case-back wrenches and home service kits are how gaskets get damaged and water resistance disappears. Pay a watchmaker instead.

Questions people actually ask

What do you buy someone who collects watches?

Something for the watches they already own: a strap cut to their wrist, a winder if they have a rotation, or a paid-for service. Seiko publishes $176 for a 4R overhaul, which makes a service one of the few gifts with a known price.

What is a good cheap gift for a watch lover?

A quality strap in the right lug width. A 316L-hardware NATO or a quick-release leather strap changes how a watch looks and costs a fraction of a watch.

Is a watch winder a good gift?

Only for someone with several automatics, a calendar watch or a watch kept in a safe. For someone with one automatic worn daily, it is a display box — give a strap instead.

How do I find out their watch's lug width?

Look up the model on the manufacturer's site, where it is usually listed as lug or band width. Every watch reviewed on this site shows it in the specification table.

Sources

Every specification and figure on this page came from one of these documents. Where a manufacturer does not publish something, the page says so rather than filling the gap.